Popjustice
  • Home
    • Briefing archive
  • Features
  • Playlists
  • Get Popjustice emails
  • About Popjustice
    • About
    • Popjustice: Est 2000
    • The Popjustice Twenty Quid Music Prize
  • Contact
    • General contact details
    • Submit music
  • Forum
Recent Posts
  • Congratulations to Charli XCX and Lorde: winners of the 2024 Popjustice Twenty Quid Music Prize
  • The 2024 Twenty Quid Music Prize: Shortlist
  • The 2023 Popjustice Twenty Quid Music Prize: Shortlist
  • Fine, let's do a Substack then.
  • The 2022 Popjustice Twenty Quid Music Prize: shortlist
Hello! In theory you should only be seeing this if you're using a mobile or tablet. How's the site looking? If anything's wonky click here and tell us so we can fix it. Thanks! x
Popjustice
  • Briefing
  • Features
  • Playlists
    • New Music Friday: The Popjustice Edit
    • Big Hit Energy
    • 21st Century Pop
    • 2018% Solid Pop Music
    • Full archive
  • About
    • About Popjustice
    • Contacting Popjustice
    • Send music
    • Popjustice: Est 2000
    • The Popjustice Twenty Quid Music Prize
  • Forum
  • Features

The 2016 Popjustice Readers’ Poll – THE RESULTS!

  • December 31, 2016
  • Popjustice

One thing we all learned in 2016 was that democracy is a valuable, powerful insti­tu­tion as long as votes go the way you want.

With that in mind brace yourself for the results of the 2016 Popjustice Readers' Poll, which rep­res­ents the crunching of numbers relating to over 2000 completed forms.

Here we go…

Best single

ariana-into-you-video
1. Ariana Grande — 'Into You'
2.
Beyoncé — 'Formation'
3. Dua Lipa — 'Hotter Than Hell'
4. Sia feat Sean Paul — 'Cheap Thrills'
5. Fifth Harmony — 'Work From Home'
6. The 1975 — 'Somebody Else'
7. Lady Gaga — 'Million Reasons'
8. Little Mix — 'Shout Out To My Ex'
9. Rihanna — 'Kiss It Better'
10. Zayn — 'Pillowtalk'
Notes: Can we talk now about the 'Into You' outro? CHRIST ALIVE! This is a space where most songs would just chuck in a final regular chorus — with 'Into You' you get the chorus taken apart and reas­sembled right before your eyes. 

Best album

beyonce-lemonade_a1. Beyoncé — 'Lemonade'
2.
Rihanna — 'Anti'
3. Lady Gaga — 'Joanne'
4. Britney Spears — 'Glory'
5. Shura — 'Nothing's Real'
6. Sia — 'This Is Acting'
7. Tove Lo — 'Ladywood'
8. Zayn — 'Mind Of Mine'
9. The 1975 — 'I Like It When You Etc'
10. Little Mix — 'Glory Days'
Notes: Finally some recog­ni­tion for under­ap­pre­ci­ated pop singer Beyoncé. Watch out for this promising talent in 2017 — something tells us she's going to do pretty well!

Worst single


1. Calum Scott — 'Dancing On My Own'
2.
Justin Timberlake — 'Can't Stop The Feeling!'
3. Lady Gaga — 'Perfect Illusion'
4. Lukas Graham — '7 Years'
5. Chainsmokers — 'Closer'
6. Meghan Trainor — 'Me Too'
7. James Arthur — 'Say You Won't Let Go'
8. Drake — 'One Dance'
9. Shawn Mendes — 'Treat You Better'
10. Bruno Mars — '24K Magic'
Notes: It's heart­en­ing here to see Justin Timberlake's half-arsed Trolls tune getting some attention. It's quite an achieve­ment, isn't it: a song about fun that sounds like not one person had any fun at all during its creation. 

Worst album

meghan-trainor-thank-you-2016-2480x2480
1. Meghan Trainor — 'Thank You'
2.
Charlie Puth — 'Nine Track Mind'
3. Britney Spears — 'Glory'
4. Lady Gaga — 'Joanne'
5. Tove Lo — 'Ladywood'
6. Zayn — 'Mind Of Mine'
7. Drake — 'Views'
8. James Arthur — 'Back From The Edge'
9. Beyoncé — 'Lemonade'
10. Fifth Harmony — '7/27'
Notes: In years gone by this poll's Worst Album category was a little strange — back when you generally had to pay to hear an album, or at least make the effort to illegally download it, votes would either be for artists people just didn't like (and whose albums they hadn't actually heard), or for dis­ap­point­ing albums by artists people DID like. A dis­ap­point­ing album's a bit different from a bad album, isn't it? Anyway thanks to the streaming era it really is now possible for all of us to get a measure of an album at a cost of £0.00 (roughly $0.00), meaning that this year's Worst Album category is probably the most accurate to date. Gaga's inclusion is likely something to do with the 'dis­ap­point­ing' factor and James Arthur's mainly there because people don't like him, but it's hard to argue with Meghan Trainor's position.

Best video

beyonce-formation
1. Beyoncé — 'Formation'
2.
Beyoncé — 'Hold Up'
3. Britney Spears feat Tinashe — 'Slumber Party'
4. Beyoncé — 'Sorry'
5. Fifth Harmony — 'Work From Home'
6. Shura — 'What's It Gonna Be?'
7. Sia — 'The Greatest'
8. Charli XCX — 'After The Afterparty'
9. Petite Meller — 'The Flute'
10. Solange — 'Cranes In The Sky'
Notes: There are some extreme health and safety viol­a­tions in a number of these videos and we'd like to see this slapdash approach tightened up in 2017. If we accept that popstars are role models then we can't just have them standing on cars or wandering around building sites holding hammers like big cocks. 

Worst video

rehost-2016-9-13-cd1c1c66-3af1-4cd4-a250-11a51883abe6
1. Britney Spears — 'Make Me'
2.
Meghan Trainor — 'Me Too'
3. Taylor Swift — 'New Romantics'
4. Lady Gaga — 'Perfect Illusion'
5. Ariana Grande — 'Into You'
6. Fifth Harmony — 'That's My Girl'
7. Justin Timberlake — 'Can't Stop The Feeling!'
8. Meghan Trainor — 'No'
9. Ariana Grande — 'Dangerous Woman'
10. Zayn — 'Pillowtalk'
Notes: A few on the list are here simply because they don't do justice to excellent tunes but as for the rest, it's inter­est­ing to imagine three things. First, imagine the original treatment, and imagine how bad the others must have been. Second, imagine how much these videos cost. Third, just think how many people saw the treat­ments, were present at the shoots, gave feedback on various edits and then finally approved these videos. Absolutely incredible.

Most absurd use of major label cash

charlie-puth
1. Charlie Puth
2.
Nathan Sykes
3. Frank Ocean's carpentry masterclass
4. Meghan Trainor
5. Britney's scrapped 'Make Me' video
6. Lady Gaga's 'Dive Bar tour'
7. Tropical house
8. Rag'n'Bone Man
9. Anti release strategy
10. M.O
Notes: YOU CAN'T HANDLE THE PUTH.

Act most likely to share the fact that they've won this category with a large number of followers

years-and-years
1. Years & Years
2.
Little Mix
3. Demi Lovato
4. Lady Gaga
5. Charli XCX
6. Jessie J
7. The 1975
8. Zara Larsson
9. Nathan Sykes
10. Dua Lipa
Notes: It's a shame Little Mix didn't win because that would have probably got a bit more "social" "traction".

Major artist with disappointing music most at odds with ability to achieve better

lady-gaga-perfect-illusio
1. Lady Gaga
2.
Little Mix
3. Tove Lo
4. Rihanna
5. Mollie King
6. Zara Larsson
7. Justin Timberlake
8. Britney Spears
9. Gwen Stefani
10. Charli XCX
Notes: Some harsh truths dotted around in this list BUT HAS ANYONE NOTICED THAT 'JOANNE' IS ACTUALLY REALLY GOOD??

Artist most likely to have voted for Brexit

barlow
1. Gary Barlow
2.
Liam Payne
3. Sam Smith
4. Kate Bush
5. James Arthur
6. Taylor Swift
7. Kanye West
8. Geri Halliwell
9. Calum Scott
10. Olly Murs
Notes: We bet Barlow did bloody vote Leave too, which is ironic con­sid­er­ing his intimate knowledge of the destruc­tion, misery and years of rebuild­ing that tend to follow one party's abrupt departure from a perfectly func­tional group. 

Disaster of the year

calum2-photo
1. Calum Scott
2.
Sam Smith's Oscars moment
3. 'Joanne'
4. Streaming fucking up the charts
5. The Chainsmokers
6. James Arthur's return
7. Tropical house
8. The X Factor
9. Fergie
10. Neil leaving Clean Bandit (?!)
Notes: A sus­pris­ingly low placing here for Tropical House. It's almost as if people actually quite like it and don't see what all the moaning is about. 

Triumph of the year

beyonce-lemonade_a
1. 'Lemonade'
2.
Beyoncébowl
3. Aspects of Ariana Grande
4. Assorted ref­er­ences to 'Lush Life''s continued success
5. Britney's 'return to form'
6. Adele at Glastonbury
7. Various ref­er­ences to Justin Bieber's penis
8. Little Mix knocking off James Arthur
9. Sia's first US Number One
10. Pet Shop Boys at Royal Opera House
Notes: No votes in this category for Cruz Beckham's Christmas single. 

Comeback of the year

craig-david-number-one
1. Craig David
2.
Britney
3. All Saints
4. Busted
5. JoJo
6. Melanie C
7. Rihanna
8. Sean Paul
9. Rick Astley
10. James Arthur
Notes: We had lunch with Craig David over the summer. Went to quite a nice res­taur­ant and were worried he'd be all like "ooh only a glass of water and a bit of lettuce for me please", as he's all muscular now isn't he? But he just kept ordering food. Plates and plates of food. There, it's fair to say, is a man who's loving life. Most of the best popstars are ones who've stared The Dumper full on in the face at some point in their career. Well, they give the best inter­views anyway. And probably eat bigger lunches. 

Best new act to properly get going in 2016

dua-lipa-dua-lipa-2017-2480x2480
1. Dua Lipa
2.
Shura
3. Zara Larsson
4. Christine & The Queens
5. Anne-Marie
6. Dagny
7. Alessia Cara
8. MØ
9. DNCE
10. Petite Meller
Notes: Dua Lipa started the year on the BBC Sound poll longlist; she ended it on the Brits Critics' Choice shortlist. 'One in the eye' for anyone who says pop music's slowing down. Look at it go! WHOOOSH — careers exploding at the speed of light.

Most ridiculous recording artist

trainor-mee-too
1. Meghan Trainor
2.
Lady Gaga
3. Robbie Williams
4. Kanye West
5. Cruz Beckham
6. The Chainsmokers
7. Mariah Carey
8. Honey G
9. Sean Paul
10. Halsey
Notes: FINALLY some recog­ni­tion for Cruz Beckham.

Best radio station

radio-1-logo
1. Radio 1
2.
'Spotify'
3. Capital
4. 'None of them'
5. Kiss
6. Beats 1
7. Heat
8. Z100
9. Radio 2
10. Heart
Notes: It's probably fair to say this Top 10 rep­res­ents something of a 'watershed moment'. 

Best DJ (on the radio)

annie-mac-16
1. Annie Mac
2.
Clara Amfo
3. Greg James
4. Nick Grimshaw
5. Scott Mills
6. Charli XCX
7. Marvin Humes
8. Emma Bunton
9. Lauren Laverne
10. Pete Allison
Notes: (Charli XCX counts because she has a show on Beats 1.)

Best TV show with music as some sort of central focus

empire
1. Empire
2.
Eurovision
3. 'None of them' / 'Are there any' / etc
4. Crazy Ex-Girlfriend
5. Songs Of Praise
6. Nashville
7. The Voice
8. The X Factor
9. RuPaul's Drag Race
10. The Get Down
Notes: Another great year for The X Factor.

Best cover version

mix_rih2000x1200
1. Rihanna — 'Same Ol' Mistakes'
2.
Little Mix — 'Ugly Heart'
3. Lorde — 'Life On Mars'
4. Betty Who — 'I Love You Always Forever'
5. Craig David — 'Love Yourself'
6. Christine & The Queens — 'Sorry'
7. Laura Mvula — 'Ready Or Not'
8. Say Lou Lou — 'Stayin' Alive'
9. Vérité — 'Somebody Else'
10. MNEK — 'Don't Stop Me Now'
Notes: So many votes for Little Mix's 'cover' in this category. 

Worst cover version

dancing-on-my-own-cover
1. Calum Scott — 'Dancing On My Own'
2.
Jonas Blue feat Dakota — 'Fast Car'
3. David Guetta — 'Would I Lie To You?'
4. Little Mix — 'Ugly Heart'
5. Betty Who — 'I Love You Always Forever'
6. 'Anything tropical'
7. Assorted Conor Maynard covers
8. Emily Middlemas — 'Toxic'
9. Kings Of Leon — 'Hands To Myself'
10. Jessie J — 'Can't Take My Eyes Off You'
Notes: And there are Little Mix again.

Best streaming service

spotify-logo
1. Spotify
2.
YouTube
3. SoundCloud
4. Apple Music
5. Deezer
6. 'None' / 'I don't bother with them' / etc
7. Bandcamp
8. Tidal
9. Amazon
10. 'Microsoft Groove Music' (‽)
Notes: 2017 will almost certainly be Tidal's year.

Newish act most likely to save pop in 2017

dua-lipa-2016
1. Dua Lipa
2.
Muna
3. Maggie Rogers
4. Raye
5. Anne-Marie
6. Saara Aalto
7. Dagny
8. Allie X
9. Tkay Maidza
10. Astrid S
Notes: At first glance you look at this Top 10 and you think, "hm, not many men here". And then you remember Rag'n'Bone Man and you think, "alright, fair play". 

Established act most likely to return and save pop in 2017

lorde-press
1. Lorde
2.
Katy Perry
3. Charli XCX
4. Robyn
5. Sky Ferreira
6. Marina & The Diamonds
7. Years & Years
8. Taylor Swift
9. Harry Styles
10. Lana Del Rey
Notes: CORRECT CORRECT CORRECT CORRECT CORRECT CORRECT CORRECT maybe CORRECT CORRECT.

Least controversial popstar

carly-rae-jepsen-sexy
1. Carly Rae Jepsen
2.
Kylie Minogue
3. Adele
4. Ellie Goulding
5. Jess Glynne
6. Emeli Sandé
7. Niall Horan
8. Birdy
9. Louisa Johnson
10. Shawn Mendes
Notes: If you think Jeppo lacks con­tro­versy we suggest you examine pho­to­graphs of her hair at Brighton Pride. 

Best use of social media by popstar or pop-related entity

zara-larsson-press
1. Zara Larsson
2.
Katy Perry
3. Cher
4. Britney Spears (with most voters making specific reference to Instagram)
5. Olly Alexander
6. Lily Allen
7. Clare Maguire
8. James Blunt
9. The 1975
10. Rihanna
Notes: In summary, it generally helps if you have something to say and the ability to say it.

Songmaking writer/producer/collective of the year

tranter-michaels-britney
1. Justin Tranter and Julia Michaels
2.
Max Martin
3. Mark Ronson
4. Bloodpop
5. Greg Kurstin
6. Dev Hynes
7. MNEK
8. Savan Kotecha
9. Sia
10. Sophie
Notes: Wait until you hear Julia Michaels' first single 'Issues'. It's coming quite soon and it's 'quite the toe-tapper'. 

Most annoying online fanbase

baby-84627_1920
1. 'All of them'
2.
Beliebers
3. Harmonizers
4. Britney Army
5. Directioners
6. Beyhive
7. Monsters
8. Madonna fans
9. Swifties
10. Mixers
Notes: Another year, another oppor­tun­ity to marvel at the fact that Madonna hasn't named her fanbase, while the fanbase hasn't even named itself. That seems to indicate restraint and respect from both sides, in a way, doesn't it?

Had it, lost it in 2016

gaga-press-2016
1. Lady Gaga
2.
Robbie Williams
3. Gwen Stefani
4. Taylor Swift
5. Kanye West
6. Emeli Sandé
7. Calvin Harris
8. Little Mix
9. Rihanna
10. Frank Ocean
Notes: Say what you like about Robbie's album (at least that way there'd be some sort of recog­ni­tion that it had actually been released), but we need more popstars who can chuck "'ave it like an oligarch" into their songs.

Didn’t have it, found it in 2016

the-1975-press
1. The 1975
2.
Ariana Grande
3. Lady Gaga
4. Zayn
5. The Chainsmokers
6. Fifth Harmony
7. Clean Bandit
8. Britney Spears
9. Childish Gambino
10. Clare Maguire
Notes: This had to be The 1975 didn't it?

Popstar with whom you would most like to tenderly make love as part of a rewarding relationship

nick-jons
1. Nick Jonas
2.
Rihanna
3. Zayn
4. Olly Alexander
5. Marina & The Diamonds
6. Shawn Mendes
7. Dua Lipa
8. Calvin Harris
9. Harry Styles
10. Beyoncé
Notes: The thing with Shawn Mendes though, surely, is that there's every danger he'd keep an acoustic guitar near the bed. 

Most deluded artist

bieber-press
1. Justin Bieber
2.
Lady Gaga
3. Meghan Trainor
4. Taylor Swift
5. Halsey
6. Kanye West
7. The Chainsmokers
8. Demi Lovato
9. Azealia Banks
10. Drake
Notes: Be real for a minute — if you had hair as good as Justin Bieber's, you'd probably be pretty pleased with yourself too. 

Least deluded artist

adele-tour-announcement
1. Adele
2.
Carly Rae Jepsen
3. Rihanna
4. Kelly Clarkson
5. JoJo
6. Sia
7. Olly Alexander
8. Lorde
9. Zara Larsson
10. Charli XCX
Notes: Relatability is a funny thing, isn't it? Supposedly relatable artists are all vastly more talented, or stylish, or funny, or attract­ive, or clever than we are. And yet we say "oh look at Adele, with her brilliant voice and her song­writ­ing talent and her sense of humour and her effort­less charisma — she's just like us". JUST LIKE WHO? WHO ARE THE PEOPLE WHO RELATE TO ADELE ON THOSE TERMS? 

Act we should send to Eurovision in 2017

little-mix-press
1. Little Mix
2.
Clean Bandit
3. GEM
4. Mollie King
5. Charli XCX
6. Fleur East
7. Dua Lipa
8. Louisa Johnson
9. Honey G
10. Saraa Aalto
Notes: If you boil this 'vote broth' down to the sludge of acts who'd actually say yes to doing it, we're looking at GEM in first place followed by Mollie, probably Fleur then Louisa Johnson. GEM would be quite funny, but at the same time very sad. It might well be for the best if we just decide to give it all a miss this year.

Worst partnership between brand and pop act

rihanna-samsung
1. Samsung / Rihanna
2.
Apple / Taylor Swift
3. EE / Britney
4. Adidas / Rita Ora
5. Orange Theory Fitness / Britney
6. Cornetto / Little Mix
7. Bud Light / Lady Gaga
8. Pantene / Ellie Goulding
9. McDonald's / Little Mix
10. Müller / Nicole Scherzinger
Notes: Sadly voting had closed by the time Paris Hilton announced her part­ner­ship with Lidl. Related: imagine if 2017 throws up a song as good as 'Stars Are Blind'. IMAGINE. 

Group most likely to split or 'take a year off' in 2017

fifth-harmony-work-from-home
1. Fifth Harmony
2.
Clean Bandit
3. GEM
4. Busted
5. The Vamps
6. Coldplay
7. All Saints
8. M.O
9. GRL
10. 5 Seconds Of Summer
Notes: Most of these votes came in before the band when com­pletely tits up in the final weeks of 2016. What does the future hold for Fifth Harmony? We're saying The Departed Member releases an album no better — but no worse — than Nicole Scherzinger's eventual debut; it will contain one song far better than anything Fifth Harmony have ever released, but three songs far worse than anything Firth Harmony have ever released. As for The Remaining Four, there'll be a brand new song in the spring to show everyone they're still a strong, united, tight unit, prior to another member leaving in June.

Social Media Arsehole Of The Year

pj0442
1. Donald Trump
2.
Azealia Banks
3. Justin Bieber
4. Piers Morgan
5. The Chainsmokers
6. Taylor Swift
7. Kanye West
8. Nigel Farage
9. Steve Brookstein
10. 'Everyone'
Notes: We were thinking of taking out the non-pop ones but then we thought: actually let's just keep them in.

Total bellend of the year

trump
1. Donald Trump
2.
Honey G
3. Justin Bieber
4. Azealia Banks
5. Dr Luke
6. Taylor Swift
7. Kanye West
8. Calum Scott
9. Nigel Farage
10. Sam Smith
Notes: Well at least it's good news for James Arthur. 

Total hero of the year

beyonce-formation-hat
1. Beyoncé
2.
Carly Rae Jepsen
3. Karen Kwak
4. Zara Larsson
5. Lady Gaga
6. Madonna
7. Rihanna
8. Olly Alexander
9. Craig David
10. Ariana Grande
Notes: Good showing here for Karen Kwak, the A&R exec respons­ible for the Britney album being sig­ni­fic­antly better than a Britney album had any right to be in 2016, and far better than anybody else connected with the project would have bothered making it.

And that brings it to a close. Thanks everyone for voting — we'll see you in 2017!

Previous Article
  • The News

George Michael has died, aged 53

  • December 25, 2016
  • Popjustice
Have a read
Next Article
  • Videos

M.O feat Kent Jones — 'Not In Love'

  • January 5, 2017
  • Brad O'Mance
Have a read
Further listening
Greatest hits
  • Mutya Keisha Siobhan: their amazingness is legally binding
  • Robbie Williams interview
  • April 30, 2265: A Warning.
Further reading
  • 1
    Congratulations to Charli XCX and Lorde: winners of the 2024 Popjustice Twenty Quid Music Prize
  • 2
    The 2024 Twenty Quid Music Prize: Shortlist
  • 3
    The 2023 Popjustice Twenty Quid Music Prize: Shortlist
  • 4
    Fine, let's do a Substack then.
  • 5
    The 2022 Popjustice Twenty Quid Music Prize: shortlist
  • 6
    2021 Popjustice Twenty Quid Music Prize: Laura Mvula wins
Est 2000. Still going.
Socials

 Spotify
 Facebook
 Twitter
 Instagram
 Soundcloud

'Quick links'

About Popjustice
Contact Popjustice
Sign up for the newsletter 
Submit music
Est 2000
Twenty Quid Music Prize 

Playlists

21st Century Pop 
New Music Friday: The Popjustice Edit 
2018% Solid Pop Music 
The Sound Of Popjustice 
Playlist archive

© 2020 Popjustice Ltd. Scrolled to the bottom now you're here
  • Privacy, Ts & Cs, cookies etc
  • Corrections

Input your search keywords and press Enter.